Tuesday, June 23, 2009

Shock-proof


This post should have been written quite a while back, when I was still reeling under the general shock of ‘thaeer sadam’ (Curd rice), ‘HR’ (pronounced hetch R), ‘where’s your native?’ and such atrocities. However, I thought I'd write about them anyway for the record, if not for anything else.

The following are a few instances when I was shocked out of my wits during my years in South India (Now that is an ignorant term…I should say, in Bangalore and Chennai). I’m sure you don’t have a clue. Let me explain.

Sample the following shockers. Most of these shockers cannot elicit a response. They are too shocking, and in most cases, I was dumb with amazement. On a few occasions, I have formed an opinion. The sections in bold, are my inputs.

1. ‘Where’s you’re native?’ First of all, this is incorrect English. It should always be ‘Where do you come from?’ This is a question that’s been bugging me since I moved to Bangalore. Later on, the question chased me till Chennai, and has stayed with me ever since.


2. ‘You are a North Indian?’ No, I come from East India, if you ask me. From a place called Calcutta, which has now been renamed to Kolkata. Kolkata is the capital city of West Bengal, which is one of the states of India. The map of the country seems to have dissolved into nothingness beyond Andhra Pradesh.
3. This is Bhanupriya from Hetch R. The moment you cross Orissa, ‘H’ becomes ‘Hetch’.

4. 'Why don't you learn Tamil'? Because I speak Hindi, which is the national language, and English which should be spoken all across the country. You have a problem? 'But I had to learn Hindi when I was in Mumbai. Why don't you learn Tamil in Tamil Nadu?' Oh, but you didn't learn Marathi. Both Marathi and Tamil are regional languages.

5. ‘Hi, I am Savitha’. That’s right. The Savita from Delhi, or Mumbai, or Kolkata, or Pune, or for that matter any other place in the world, becomes a ‘Savitha’ in the south of India. South Indian logic is that ‘th’ is the soft pronunciation. ‘Savita’ without the ‘H’ is much like ‘Beta’ with a sharp ‘T’ which is wrong. Okay, let’s agree for a change.
Now there is this place down the road that serves decent food and you also get live music over the weekends. So what’s it called? Ladies and gentlemen, it is called ‘Khaana Ghaana’. Now why that ‘h’ in ‘Ghaana’? Is it a piece of Africa? Does the removal of ‘h’ in ‘Ghaana’ make it a sharp pronunciation? How can you pronounce ‘Gaana’ sharply? Beats me.

The other day, a Bong friend called up...he knew about my general intolerance towards the unnecessary 'H' in Tamil English. The following bit is in Bengali:

"Aami ekhane Vellore-er Golden Temple-e eshechchi...bujhli? It says 'way to Dharshan'!" Bongs, stop doubling up with laughter!


6. ‘Satyajit Ray is a great director? Is he so famous?’ As famous as Balachander? No comments.


7. ‘Sean Penn won the Oscars. Great actor…what do you say?’ Oh but he is so subtle. Actors should be like Shivaji Ganesan. No comments.


8. King Lear? Never heard of him. The story that you tell me sounds like a Tamil movie. No comments.

And the hits just keep on coming. By the time I leave Chennai, if I ever do, I will be shock-proof. That’s a promise, to whoever is listening.

5 comments:

Debashish Paul said...

I just loved this post and was on the floor laughing when I read " Ladies and gentlemen, it is called ‘Khaana Ghaana’". My Gawd!!! this is very frustrating I understand but, you know these things just follow wherever you go. Ask me!!! since I've been born in Punjab and brought up almost across India. I have faced this everywhere and as a child you don't tend to be shocked but you get into it and used to it. That is why till date I have problems with my language no matter, it is Hindi, English or Bengali I am not strong in any of these. But at the brighter side I can understand and speak tamil, kannada, Punjabi, Marathi etc :P

But, What you wrote is just hillarious. I understand... :)

Scribbler :) said...

I am not such a pro-South-Indian resident as you. But in that 1 year that I was there, AmitH and myself decided that life was pretty 'sour' down south (with all the curd, tamarind and sambhar). As for the 'Hetch'...I thank my phonetic stars that I left just before my ears got so used to them that my tongue started imitating.

Elango said...

Are you hindi? Do you speak hindu? This is a popular US view of all Indians. When I was in Chattisgargh people asked if I am from Kerala and if I speak telugu. A major population in the country doesn't know the most ancient language in India. The CBSE books at the national level have been done with so less research, as I can see rest of India has no knowledge of the literary wealth and architectural splendour of the south. Tamil is in fact an international language , an official language in 5 other countries other than India. The national policy and centralized policy has resulted in naxals fighting with bows and arrows in Bengal. Any society which marginalises ancient people and it's knowledge will trail behind. ray and Amitav Gosh are talked about but there are thousands of performers and writers which others are ignorant about. It is only relative to talk about shocks and ignorance.

Debanjana said...

Of course it is relative Elango, but I will only talk about the kind of experiences I have in Chennai,and that is why it is my blog, more than anything else. Maybe its a misfortune that I have not till date met a cosmopolitan Tamilian

Ram Iyer said...

i sort of read this accidentally.. but i am sure i agree with elango.. not because its relative to get shocked.. i have got shocked in more ways in Chennai myself..what with ppl saying "i went to faarin last week far hani mun".. or "yeaay.. what ya.. why nothing is occurring today" .. tamilians have a slightly above normal superfluousness with the vernacular interference.. which sort of is quite a poetic melange of absurity, naivity, flippant overlooking, and general lethargy to know the nuances..
But the news is it was in Kolkata that i heard PT sirs saying "All the both of you hurry slowly to my room and my stick the bring".. or Mr.Anirban bhaumik saying.." its a bhery bhery imbhartant bhansan of the left auricle" back in 8th standard
So.. i am sure just as we love the hungry tide and feluda's long list of cases.. we also enjoy listening to Jittu krishnamurthy's erudition and T.N Seshan's expert political opinions, or Cho's keen and audacious spontaneity..
so shocking is everywhere.. for, wherever we are, we are all humans.. Although i was literally clutching my stomach laughing, with tears in my eyes... I also felt that making provision for the "erring" aspect is essential